We have a honeysuckle pillow they all love. It makes its rounds though the house lol.
We have a crinkle bag that Logan adores. The best toys seem to be not toys. Dryer sheets, tabs from gallon milk jugs, pop bottle lids, balled up receipts. Kisa loves elastics so we have to be sure to keep them out of her range...she will dig in the garbage if she sees or smells one so special disposal is required lol.
Laser pointer is a hit too, but they're so lazy it only lasts for five or so minutes at a time.
Jordan has a stuffed monkey she likes beating up on, it's funny cuz it's almost as big as she is and she drags it around in her mouth like its a kitten.