EVO 95% is definitely cheaper than Taste of the Wild, especially as 13.2 oz cans, at least on petfooddirect.com where I order food. The chicken & turkey, the other "cat food" and the beef one are 21.99 for 12 cans of 13.2 oz. They have other varieties as well...I ordered 2 cases of the variety pack which also includes the duck and the venison. I think that was about $27. I also agree with the Trader Joe's wet food suggestion; it's $0.69/can. I stopped at Trader Joe's just before Hurricane Sandy hit and I was happy to see they offer cat food without byproducts. I picked up a few cans just to make sure I don't run out in the aftermath and my cat scarfed it down.
Zilla, thanks for the suggestion of The Honest Chicken. I might get that next time. Cutting up a beef heart was the most disgusting hour of my life. Two hours later and 7 or 8 hand-washings later (I couldn't get the smell off of my hands!) , I tried to eat a pickle and almost threw up. The experience, the smell...not to be repeated, I don't think.