Isn't Organix fairly expensive? I haven't much experience with those brands. We bought a few of the Hills Prescription ones for the dog after surgery and it was very soft pate, I agree.
Have you looked into Chicken Soup, Felidae, California Natural, Innova or Evo (Evo being grain free!)... they're less expensive than a lot of foods as they come in the 13 oz tins. I think the chicken Felidae is pretty soft compared to a lot of other pates.
I went and dug up a chart I'd saved the link to that was posted on here a few months back that I found helpful, if you're looking for chunks vs pate.
Canned Cat food Spreadsheets
Wow, thanks for posting that link! Somehow, I missed it.
Organix is really expensive, as is the Hill's a/d (nearly $2/5.5 oz can). Actually, a lot of the ones I've tried are pretty expensive. But if they'll actually eat a good quality food instead of just licking or sniffing it, I'll buy it.
luvmyfurbabies, for a couple of weeks, I was able to rotate Nutro Max, Evo, Avoderm, Wellness Core, and Blue Wilderness with Fancy Feast. But after 5 or 6 times, they stopped eating all of them. I try to sneak a can in every now and then, even tried mixing them with Fancy Feast, but they'll only eat the Nutro Max once in a while.
They both flat out refused other Blue, other Wellness, Felidae, California Natural, Dave's, Taste of the Wild, BFF, Merrick's BG, Canyon Creek Ranch, Spot's, GO, Evanger's, Natural Balance, Natural Planet Organics, Solid Gold, Tiki Cat...maybe some others.
They both liked Nature's Variety Instinct rabbit, but then I learned from doodlebug that it's sourced in China, and I don't want to feed it anymore.
Margaux wouldn't touch Hound & Gatos, and Celia wouldn't touch Weruva, Soulistic, or the Petsmart brand (can't remember the name but it's just like Weruva and Soulistic).
I'll look for Chicken Soup or Innova. Earthborne looks kind of chunky? I'm about to try something called Nutrisource.
mybabiesdaddy, yep, I can't tell you how much food's gone into the garbage disposal. At least the extra cans I could give to the local shelter. Geez.