Good canned catfood? - Cat Forum : Cat Discussion Forums
CatForum.com is the premier Cat Forum on the internet. Registered Users do not see the above ads.
Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 08-14-2004, 09:31 PM   #1 (permalink)
Senior Cat
 
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 818
Default Good canned catfood?

Anyone have any sugestions about well balanced - not to mention have a lot of MEAT catfood? I'm really looking for stuff - I saw how much meat Eukanuba puts in their dog food and I was very upset to find that they do not have canned catfood! Does anyone have any sugestions?

I'm thinking about switching from Science diet to Eukanuba dry - but the wet food has still got me baffled. If the wet food is good enough - I might just get wet and forget about the dry all together.
__________________
"Dogs come when they're called; cats take a message and get back to you later."
-Mary Bly
Gabreilla Moushigo is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Old 08-14-2004, 10:56 PM   #2 (permalink)
Tom Cat
 
opokki's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2003
Location: NY
Posts: 284
Default

I really like Innova, Eagle Pack and Wellness canned cat foods.
opokki is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-14-2004, 11:16 PM   #3 (permalink)
Jr. Cat
 
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 77
Default

I like "Wellness" canned food as well as dry.
Adora is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-15-2004, 09:44 AM   #4 (permalink)
Cool Cat
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Stoney Creek, ON
Posts: 1,068
Default

Wellness, Eagle Pack, Natural Balance, Nutro, California Natural, Newman's Own.......
__________________
There really is nothing better than a weekend!
Maleke is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 08-15-2004, 11:16 AM   #5 (permalink)
Cool Cat
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 922
Default

Oh here we go... I really need to finish my chart and upload it, this is all getting to long hahaha.


Scale from 1 - 10
* indicates preferred
^ indicates supplimental feeding only
+ indicates contains meat by-products (a poor food source)
Products are rated by first meat content, protein (of 11% +) and fiber percentage (of 1% -) only, it does not take into account the actual source of ingredients good or bad. Though a food marked as preferred means the ingredients are human grade and fresh. Example by meaning even a 3rd rated food could be better then some higher rated food if it is marked as preferred.

Rated: 10
Old Mother Hubbard - Cod, Sole & Haddock +

Rated: 9
Nutro Gourmet - Slamon & Whitefish
Nutro Natural Choice - Lamb & Kidney
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Salmon +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Tuna +

Rated: 8
Felidae - Chicken & Lamb*
Chicken Soup for the Kitten Lovers Soul*
Eagle Pack - Salmon & Shrimp
Natural Life - Seafood & Veggie
Nutro Max - Chicken & Liver
Old Mother Hubbard - Tuna, Haddock & Egg +


Rated: 7
Pinnacle - Chicken & Tuna*
Chicken Soup for the Cat Lovers Soul*
AvoDerm - Beef
Azmira - Beef & Chicken
Azmira - Ocean Fish
Fancy Feast - Chicken & Tuna Feast +
Fancy Feast - Tuna & Mackerel Feast
Fancy Feast - Cod, Sole & Shrimp Feast +
Hi Tor - Felo Diet +
Iams - Maturity Chicken & Rice +
Iams - Maturity Fish & Rice +
Iams - Kitten +
Natural Life - Ocean Fish & Veggie
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Oceanfish & Tuna
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Salmon & Oceanfish
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Turkey & Giblets
Nutro Natural Choice - Turkey & Liver
Nutro Gourmet - Beef & Egg
Nutro Gourmet - California Chicken Supreme
Nutro Gourmet - Lamb & Turkey
Nutro Gourmet - Seafood & Tomato Bisque
Nutro Gourmet - Turkey & Liver
Nutro Gourmet - Veal Pate
Nutro Max - Chicken & Lamb
Nutro Max - Ocean Fish
Nutro Max - Turkey & Giblets
Nutro Natural Choice - Chicken & Lamb
Nutro Natural Choice - Chicken Casserole
Old Mother Hubbard - Chicken, Ocean Whitefish & Egg +
PetGuard - Chicken & Wheat Germ *
PetGuard - Fish, Chicken & Liver *
Precise - Beef
Precise - Deluxe Medley
Precise - Simmered Seafare



Rated: 6
Natural Balance - Ocean Fish*
Natural Balance - Ultra*
Pinnacle - Chicken & Ocean Fish*
Pinnacle - Ocean Fish*
Wellness - Chicken & Herring*
Wellness - Turkey & Salmon*
AvoDerm - Chicken
AvoDerm - Ocean Fish
Diamond - Beef +
Eagle Pack - Ocean Fish & Tuna
Fancy Feast - Chicken Feast +
Fancy Feast - Trout Feast
Fancy Feast - Tuna Feast +
Fancy Feast - Gourmet Chicken Feast +
Fancy Feast - Ocean White Fish & Tuna Feast +
Iams - Catfish
Iams - Lamb & Rice +
Natural Life - Chicken Seafood & Veggie
Nutro Gourmet - Hunters Stew with Venison
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Chicken +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Liver +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef, Egg & Cheese +
Old Mother Hubbard - Turkey & Giblets +
PetGuard - Beef & Wheat Germ *
Precise - Fabulous Mixed Grill
Precise - Triple Delight
Precise - Plus Adult Botanicals
PRO PAC - Beef
PRO PAC - Ocean Fish
TimberWolf Organics - Omega Fish *


Rated: 5
Azmira - Lamb & Barley
California Natural - Deep Water Fish & Rice *
Diamond - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
Eagle Pack - Chicken & Lamb
Eagle Pack - Holistic Turkey & Barley
Evolve - Chicken
Evolve - Turkey
Excel - Beef
Excel - Chicken +
Excel - Turkey +
Fancy Feast - Salmon & Ocean White Fish Feast +
Hi Tor - Neo Diet +
Science Diet - Growth Liver & Chicken
Iams - Beef
Iams - Ocean Fish
Iams - Salmon
Lick Your Chops - Beef & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Seafood & Brown Rice
Natural Balance - Turkey & Giblet
Natural Life - Lamaderm
Natural Life - Chicken Turkey & Veggie
Nature's Variety - Chicken & Turkey *
Nutro Gourmet - Hunters Stew with Duck
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Beef +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Seafood +
Pet Gold - Beef
PetGuard - Premium Feast Dinner *
PetGuard - Savory Seafood *
Precise - Ocean Fish
PRO PAC - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
PRO PAC - Chicken & Liver
Triumph Beef N' Tuna +
Triumph - Chicken N' Whitefish +
Wellness - Beef & Chicken *
Wellness - Chicken *
Wellness - Turkey *
ZuPreem - Exotic Feline *



Rated: 4
Active Life - Ocean Fish
Boulder Creek Farms - Ground Beef
Alpo - Poultry Dinner +
California Natural - Chicken & Brown Rice *
California Natural - Venison & Rice *
Evolve - Seafood
Excel - Ocean Fish
Fancy Feast - Fish & Shrimp Feast
Fancy Feast - Beef & Chicken +
Fancy Feast - Beef & Liver +
Science Diet - Growth Ocean Fish +
Science Diet - Adult Beef +
Science Diet - Adult Beef & Gravy +
Science Diet - Adult Ocean Fish & Sauce +
Science Diet - Adult Seafood +
Iams - Chicken +
Iams - Turkey & Giblets +
Lick Your Chops - Chicken & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Lamb & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Turkey & Brown Rice
Natural Balance - Turkey & Giblets *
Natural Life - Chicken & Veggie
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Chicken
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Lamb
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Tuna
Nature's Recipe - Maintenance Rabbit & Rice +
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Chicken & Liver
Old Mother Hubbard - Liver & Egg +
Old Mother Hubbard - Liver +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Salmon +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Seafood, Chicken Entree
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Turkey & Giblets +
Pet Gold - Chicken & Liver
Pet Gold - Ocean Fish
Pet Gold - Tuna ^
PetGuard - Natural Beef & Barley *
PetGuard - Turkey & Rice *
Precise - Chicken
Precise - Turkey
Pro Plan - Classic Chicken & Liver +
Pro Plan - Classic Ocean Whitefish & Salmon Entree +
Pro Plan - Ground Beef & Liver Entree
Pro Plan - Ground Turkey & Giblets Entree
Sheba - Chicken Cuts +
Sheba - Crab +
Sheba - Beef +
Sheba - Turkey +
Triumph - Chicken N' Liver +
Triumph - Gourmet Beef +
Triumph - Gourmet Chicken +
Triumph - Gourmet Turkey +
Triumph - Turkey +
Triumph - Turkey, Rice 'N Vegetable +
Wysong - Beef ^
Wysong - Chicken ^
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Ocean Whitefish & Tuna +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Cod & Shrimp +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Turkey & Giblets +
Whiskas - Ground Chicken & Tuna +

Rated: 3
Alpo - Beef +
Alpo - Turkey & Giblets +
Alpo - Chicken & Rice +
Alpo - Salmon & Shrimp +
Fancy Feast - Chopped Grilled Feast +
Fancy Feast - Ocean Fish Feast
Felidae - Chicken & Rice
Hi Tor - Resudo Diet +
Innova - Adult *
Science Diet - Adult Liver & Chicken
Science Diet - Adult Chicken & Gravy +
Science Diet - Adult Turkey
Science Diet - Mixit +
Nature's Variety - Beef *
Nature's Variety - Duck *
Nature's Variety - Lamb *
Nature's Variety - Rabbit *
Nature's Variety - Venison *
Old Mother Hubbard - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
Old Mother Hubbard - Cod, Sole * Shrimp +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Chicken +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections OceanFish & Tuna +
Pet Gold - Turkey, Rice & Vegetable
Pet Gold - Seafood Cocktail & Calamari ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna & Shrimp ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna & Crab Surimi ^
Pro Plan - Ocean Fish & Crabmeat
Solid Gold - Tuna ^
TimberWolf Organics - Venison & Herbs *
Triumph - Beef N' Chicken +
Triumph - Been N' Slamon +
Triumph - Beef +
Triumph - Beef, Liver N' Bacon +
Triumph - Beef, Tuna N' Chicken +
Wysong - Gourmet Chicken *
Wysong - Gourmet Liver *
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Chicken & Liver +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Chicken & Salmon +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Turkey +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Beef +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Freshwater Trout +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Mixed Grill
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Poached Salmon +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Tuna +
Whiskas - Ground Chicken +
Whiskas - Ground Kitty Stew +
Whiskas - Ground Mealtime +
Whiskas - Ground Veal +
Whiskas - Ground 'Bits O' Beef' +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Ocean WhiteFish & Tuna +

Rated: 2
Alpo - Ocean White Fish +
Alpo - Savory Grill +
Alpo - Chicken & Gravy +
Alpo - Tuna Dinner +
Alpo - Tuna & Rice +
Evangers - Seafood
Pet Gold - Fisherman Basket & Lobster ^
Pet Gold - Sardines & Prawns ^
Pet Gold - Catch of the Day & Crab ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Prawn ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Calamari ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Crab ^
PetGuard - Rabbit & Rice ^
PetGuard - Venison & Rice ^
Pro Plan - Chicken & Rice Entree +
Pro Plan - Salmon & Rice Entree +
Sensible Choice - Chicken & Rice
Triumph - Beef Stew +
Triumph - Ocean Fish
Triumph - Salmon +
Triumph - Trout +
Wysong - Anergen
Wysong - Gourmet Seafood *
Wysong - Vitality *
Whiskas - Chicken *
Whiskas - Ground Turkey & Giblets +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Beef +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Tuna +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Chicken +


Rated 1:
Halo - Chicken & Clams
Halo - Orginial
Wysong - Rabbit ^
Wysong - Duck ^
Wysong - Venison ^
Wysong - Chicken ^
Wysong - Beef ^
Wysong - Turkey ^


Or if you want a simpler answer to foods with most meat that a good brands. Here's a few, in order

Felidae Chicken & Lamb
Pinnacle: Chicken & Tuna
Wysong: Beef
Wysong: Chicken
Natural Balance: Ocean Fish
Natural Balance: Ultra
Pinnacle: Chicken & Ocean Fish
Pinnacle: Ocean Fish
Wellness: Chicken & Herring
Wellness: Turkey & Salmon
AngelZoo is offline   Reply With Quote
Sponsored Links
Advertisement
 
Reply

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:22 AM.



Powered by vBulletin® Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
SEO by vBSEO 3.3.2
PetGuide.com
Basset.net DobermanTalk.com GoldenRetrieverForum.com OurBeagleWorld.com
BoxerForums.com DogForums.com GoPitbull.com PoodleForum.com
BulldogBreeds.com FishForums.com HavaneseForum.com SpoiledMaltese.com
CatForum.com GermanShepherds.com Labradoodle-dogs.net YorkieForum.com
Chihuahua-People.com RetrieverBreeds.com