another trek geek here and as far as movies go, in my mind it is a landslide - KHAAAAAN!
in a distant second - first contact
jj did, imo, an excellent job with star trek. i loved that he made sure to put in quite a few little "nods" to trek canon, i especially loved the mention of archers beagle.
to me a harder question is what order to rate the series.
"In studying the traits and dispositions of the so-called lower animals, and contrasting them with man's, I find the result humiliating to me."