Update: The 3 meals really seem to be helping Apollo. Athena seems like she could go either way, but basically what I am doing now is:
In the morning: 1/2 5.5oz can for Apollo, a little less for Athena.
When I get home from work: Athena gets her remaining portion from the 1/2 can, and Apollo gets another 1/4 can.
Dinner: 1/2 can each.
No raw at the moment, just for a few days. I just needed to get them eating again and see if the 3 mealtimes would help. Eric comes home on Wednesday and with him there to help out, making changes again should be easier.
Now my next question: Do you think it's possible to transition them back onto the Primal? Or once they've decided they hate it, will they never eat it again? Apollo has done this with other foods before and will still not touch them, months later. What would be the best way to reintroduce it...just the usual slow transition, increasing the proportions of raw to canned?
My local store is supposedly getting a new brand of raw in soon, so hopefully I will have some more options.
I'm still keeping frankenprey in the back of my mind as another possibility...it just seems like there are so many factors making it difficult right now. I still can't find the organ meats I need and ordering organ meats online for me is even more expensive than buying commercial raw locally.