Decided to join the forum to read about what others are experiencing with their "Furry guys." I feed my two cats dry food, but like to supplement their diet with canned food every day. They've been eating Natural Balance (duck, venison, and indoor). Thought they both liked it (Chester, my older cat is a bit more picky than Piper, the younger girl). Lately however, it's been hit or miss. Sometimes one will eat some, and the other won't; then they'll trade off the next time. Feed them both from the same can. I think they get together before meal times and decide who will act really picky just to mess with me .
I've previously tried Wellness, and they didn't seem that thrilled. I made a list of canned foods from Petco with good reviews and ingredients. About to go off and buy a couple of cans of each brand and see how it goes. Don't want to go the Fancy Feast route, but wondering if I can't find anything they seem to like, whether feeding them FF is better than nothing; keeping in mind that their main source of food is the dry mix (half and half Natural Balance and Wellmess indoor varieties).