Cat Forum banner

1 - 5 of 5 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
560 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Anyone have any sugestions about well balanced - not to mention have a lot of MEAT catfood? I'm really looking for stuff - I saw how much meat Eukanuba puts in their dog food and I was very upset to find that they do not have canned catfood! Does anyone have any sugestions?

I'm thinking about switching from Science diet to Eukanuba dry - but the wet food has still got me baffled. If the wet food is good enough - I might just get wet and forget about the dry all together.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
821 Posts
Wellness, Eagle Pack, Natural Balance, Nutro, California Natural, Newman's Own.......
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
676 Posts
Oh here we go... I really need to finish my chart and upload it, this is all getting to long hahaha.


Scale from 1 - 10
* indicates preferred
^ indicates supplimental feeding only
+ indicates contains meat by-products (a poor food source)
Products are rated by first meat content, protein (of 11% +) and fiber percentage (of 1% -) only, it does not take into account the actual source of ingredients good or bad. Though a food marked as preferred means the ingredients are human grade and fresh. Example by meaning even a 3rd rated food could be better then some higher rated food if it is marked as preferred.

Rated: 10
Old Mother Hubbard - Cod, Sole & Haddock +

Rated: 9
Nutro Gourmet - Slamon & Whitefish
Nutro Natural Choice - Lamb & Kidney
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Salmon +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Tuna +

Rated: 8
Felidae - Chicken & Lamb*
Chicken Soup for the Kitten Lovers Soul*
Eagle Pack - Salmon & Shrimp
Natural Life - Seafood & Veggie
Nutro Max - Chicken & Liver
Old Mother Hubbard - Tuna, Haddock & Egg +


Rated: 7
Pinnacle - Chicken & Tuna*
Chicken Soup for the Cat Lovers Soul*
AvoDerm - Beef
Azmira - Beef & Chicken
Azmira - Ocean Fish
Fancy Feast - Chicken & Tuna Feast +
Fancy Feast - Tuna & Mackerel Feast
Fancy Feast - Cod, Sole & Shrimp Feast +
Hi Tor - Felo Diet +
Iams - Maturity Chicken & Rice +
Iams - Maturity Fish & Rice +
Iams - Kitten +
Natural Life - Ocean Fish & Veggie
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Oceanfish & Tuna
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Salmon & Oceanfish
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Turkey & Giblets
Nutro Natural Choice - Turkey & Liver
Nutro Gourmet - Beef & Egg
Nutro Gourmet - California Chicken Supreme
Nutro Gourmet - Lamb & Turkey
Nutro Gourmet - Seafood & Tomato Bisque
Nutro Gourmet - Turkey & Liver
Nutro Gourmet - Veal Pate
Nutro Max - Chicken & Lamb
Nutro Max - Ocean Fish
Nutro Max - Turkey & Giblets
Nutro Natural Choice - Chicken & Lamb
Nutro Natural Choice - Chicken Casserole
Old Mother Hubbard - Chicken, Ocean Whitefish & Egg +
PetGuard - Chicken & Wheat Germ *
PetGuard - Fish, Chicken & Liver *
Precise - Beef
Precise - Deluxe Medley
Precise - Simmered Seafare



Rated: 6
Natural Balance - Ocean Fish*
Natural Balance - Ultra*
Pinnacle - Chicken & Ocean Fish*
Pinnacle - Ocean Fish*
Wellness - Chicken & Herring*
Wellness - Turkey & Salmon*
AvoDerm - Chicken
AvoDerm - Ocean Fish
Diamond - Beef +
Eagle Pack - Ocean Fish & Tuna
Fancy Feast - Chicken Feast +
Fancy Feast - Trout Feast
Fancy Feast - Tuna Feast +
Fancy Feast - Gourmet Chicken Feast +
Fancy Feast - Ocean White Fish & Tuna Feast +
Iams - Catfish
Iams - Lamb & Rice +
Natural Life - Chicken Seafood & Veggie
Nutro Gourmet - Hunters Stew with Venison
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Chicken +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef & Liver +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef +
Old Mother Hubbard - Beef, Egg & Cheese +
Old Mother Hubbard - Turkey & Giblets +
PetGuard - Beef & Wheat Germ *
Precise - Fabulous Mixed Grill
Precise - Triple Delight
Precise - Plus Adult Botanicals
PRO PAC - Beef
PRO PAC - Ocean Fish
TimberWolf Organics - Omega Fish *


Rated: 5
Azmira - Lamb & Barley
California Natural - Deep Water Fish & Rice *
Diamond - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
Eagle Pack - Chicken & Lamb
Eagle Pack - Holistic Turkey & Barley
Evolve - Chicken
Evolve - Turkey
Excel - Beef
Excel - Chicken +
Excel - Turkey +
Fancy Feast - Salmon & Ocean White Fish Feast +
Hi Tor - Neo Diet +
Science Diet - Growth Liver & Chicken
Iams - Beef
Iams - Ocean Fish
Iams - Salmon
Lick Your Chops - Beef & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Seafood & Brown Rice
Natural Balance - Turkey & Giblet
Natural Life - Lamaderm
Natural Life - Chicken Turkey & Veggie
Nature's Variety - Chicken & Turkey *
Nutro Gourmet - Hunters Stew with Duck
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Beef +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Seafood +
Pet Gold - Beef
PetGuard - Premium Feast Dinner *
PetGuard - Savory Seafood *
Precise - Ocean Fish
PRO PAC - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
PRO PAC - Chicken & Liver
Triumph Beef N' Tuna +
Triumph - Chicken N' Whitefish +
Wellness - Beef & Chicken *
Wellness - Chicken *
Wellness - Turkey *
ZuPreem - Exotic Feline *



Rated: 4
Active Life - Ocean Fish
Boulder Creek Farms - Ground Beef
Alpo - Poultry Dinner +
California Natural - Chicken & Brown Rice *
California Natural - Venison & Rice *
Evolve - Seafood
Excel - Ocean Fish
Fancy Feast - Fish & Shrimp Feast
Fancy Feast - Beef & Chicken +
Fancy Feast - Beef & Liver +
Science Diet - Growth Ocean Fish +
Science Diet - Adult Beef +
Science Diet - Adult Beef & Gravy +
Science Diet - Adult Ocean Fish & Sauce +
Science Diet - Adult Seafood +
Iams - Chicken +
Iams - Turkey & Giblets +
Lick Your Chops - Chicken & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Lamb & Brown Rice
Lick Your Chops - Turkey & Brown Rice
Natural Balance - Turkey & Giblets *
Natural Life - Chicken & Veggie
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Chicken
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Lamb
Nature's Recipe - Lifestages Adult Julienne Tuna
Nature's Recipe - Maintenance Rabbit & Rice +
Nutro Natural Choice (Pouches) - Adult Chicken & Liver
Old Mother Hubbard - Liver & Egg +
Old Mother Hubbard - Liver +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Salmon +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Seafood, Chicken Entree
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Turkey & Giblets +
Pet Gold - Chicken & Liver
Pet Gold - Ocean Fish
Pet Gold - Tuna ^
PetGuard - Natural Beef & Barley *
PetGuard - Turkey & Rice *
Precise - Chicken
Precise - Turkey
Pro Plan - Classic Chicken & Liver +
Pro Plan - Classic Ocean Whitefish & Salmon Entree +
Pro Plan - Ground Beef & Liver Entree
Pro Plan - Ground Turkey & Giblets Entree
Sheba - Chicken Cuts +
Sheba - Crab +
Sheba - Beef +
Sheba - Turkey +
Triumph - Chicken N' Liver +
Triumph - Gourmet Beef +
Triumph - Gourmet Chicken +
Triumph - Gourmet Turkey +
Triumph - Turkey +
Triumph - Turkey, Rice 'N Vegetable +
Wysong - Beef ^
Wysong - Chicken ^
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Ocean Whitefish & Tuna +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Cod & Shrimp +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Turkey & Giblets +
Whiskas - Ground Chicken & Tuna +

Rated: 3
Alpo - Beef +
Alpo - Turkey & Giblets +
Alpo - Chicken & Rice +
Alpo - Salmon & Shrimp +
Fancy Feast - Chopped Grilled Feast +
Fancy Feast - Ocean Fish Feast
Felidae - Chicken & Rice
Hi Tor - Resudo Diet +
Innova - Adult *
Science Diet - Adult Liver & Chicken
Science Diet - Adult Chicken & Gravy +
Science Diet - Adult Turkey
Science Diet - Mixit +
Nature's Variety - Beef *
Nature's Variety - Duck *
Nature's Variety - Lamb *
Nature's Variety - Rabbit *
Nature's Variety - Venison *
Old Mother Hubbard - Chicken, Rice & Lamb
Old Mother Hubbard - Cod, Sole * Shrimp +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections Chicken +
Old Mother Hubbard - Savory Selections OceanFish & Tuna +
Pet Gold - Turkey, Rice & Vegetable
Pet Gold - Seafood Cocktail & Calamari ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna & Shrimp ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna & Crab Surimi ^
Pro Plan - Ocean Fish & Crabmeat
Solid Gold - Tuna ^
TimberWolf Organics - Venison & Herbs *
Triumph - Beef N' Chicken +
Triumph - Been N' Slamon +
Triumph - Beef +
Triumph - Beef, Liver N' Bacon +
Triumph - Beef, Tuna N' Chicken +
Wysong - Gourmet Chicken *
Wysong - Gourmet Liver *
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Chicken & Liver +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Chicken & Salmon +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Turkey +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Beef +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Freshwater Trout +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Mixed Grill
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Poached Salmon +
Whiskas Choice Cuts - Tuna +
Whiskas - Ground Chicken +
Whiskas - Ground Kitty Stew +
Whiskas - Ground Mealtime +
Whiskas - Ground Veal +
Whiskas - Ground 'Bits O' Beef' +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Ocean WhiteFish & Tuna +

Rated: 2
Alpo - Ocean White Fish +
Alpo - Savory Grill +
Alpo - Chicken & Gravy +
Alpo - Tuna Dinner +
Alpo - Tuna & Rice +
Evangers - Seafood
Pet Gold - Fisherman Basket & Lobster ^
Pet Gold - Sardines & Prawns ^
Pet Gold - Catch of the Day & Crab ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Prawn ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Calamari ^
Pet Gold Elite - Tuna, Rice & Crab ^
PetGuard - Rabbit & Rice ^
PetGuard - Venison & Rice ^
Pro Plan - Chicken & Rice Entree +
Pro Plan - Salmon & Rice Entree +
Sensible Choice - Chicken & Rice
Triumph - Beef Stew +
Triumph - Ocean Fish
Triumph - Salmon +
Triumph - Trout +
Wysong - Anergen
Wysong - Gourmet Seafood *
Wysong - Vitality *
Whiskas - Chicken *
Whiskas - Ground Turkey & Giblets +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Beef +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Tuna +
Whiskas - Tender Bite Chicken +


Rated 1:
Halo - Chicken & Clams
Halo - Orginial
Wysong - Rabbit ^
Wysong - Duck ^
Wysong - Venison ^
Wysong - Chicken ^
Wysong - Beef ^
Wysong - Turkey ^


Or if you want a simpler answer to foods with most meat that a good brands. Here's a few, in order :)

Felidae Chicken & Lamb
Pinnacle: Chicken & Tuna
Wysong: Beef
Wysong: Chicken
Natural Balance: Ocean Fish
Natural Balance: Ultra
Pinnacle: Chicken & Ocean Fish
Pinnacle: Ocean Fish
Wellness: Chicken & Herring
Wellness: Turkey & Salmon
 
1 - 5 of 5 Posts
Top