Oh, if she isn't allowed out at night I would just stick with your consistency and refuse her request/demand, but I'd also discourage her scratching to get her way. I'd maybe clap my hands sharply, tell her a stern "No!" or threaten to go over and *make* her move away from the door or shake a squirt bottle at her to make her leave scratching at the door.
As for the handling issue ... maybe some cats just don't *like* to be handled ... but I have NEVER had a cat that I could not pick up and handle in any way I wished (belly rubs, holding their feet, holding them upside down like a baby, smooching them ~ all w/out being bitten/scratched) and I have had up to 80-90 cats throughout my entire life. I'm not tooting my own horn, but surely if it were true that "some cats just don't like to be handled" the odds would have given me a cat I could not handle? So, I must conclude that my handling methods are different from most people and cats who don't like to be handled are allowed to be that way by their handlers. I do not allow my cats to refuse to be handled ... and most of my cats were adult ferals I tamed myself.
I have no other explanation...