LOL! As for 18 treats a day...holy smokes! My girls only receive typical cat treats (Go/Now grain free or Pure Bites freeze dried). They get 2 or 3 treats at bedtime and perhaps another 2 to 4 during the day, but like saitenyo, I only give them those extra ones for specific purposes. As for other foods that they "love" such as the type you mentioned, I rarely feed them "people food" (maybe once every few months) and I never give them Fancy Feast and the like. I always worry that if I started, I'd then have trouble getting them to eat their healthy foods!My cats are apparently eating treats for every meal.