Cat Forum banner

Question for the catsperts

2461 Views 15 Replies 8 Participants Last post by  BroganMc
Hello!
I have a calico kitten. I live downtown Montreal and want her to be an indoor cat. That being said. I have been putting her on a harness and leash and let her roam on the balcony and take her to parks now and then but only on a leash. Is this a bad idea?
Will she want to be an outdoor cat if I keep doing this?
I live on the second floor. I'm always eith her at all times when she's roaming on her leash. I just want to be the best momma to her and raise her right.

Also...
The vet told me that I should play with her and tease her get her rowdy and it's ok if she bites and scratches because that is her way of playing and she thinks I'm her mom or litter mate. When she gets intense he told me to tug at the scruff.
I just want your opinions because like I said I want to raise the best cat.

Thank you for your time all :)
Lili
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
Also...
The vet told me that I should play with her and tease her get her rowdy and it's ok if she bites and scratches because that is her way of playing and she thinks I'm her mom or litter mate. When she gets intense he told me to tug at the scruff.
I just want your opinions because like I said I want to raise the best cat.

Thank you for your time all :)
Lili
When I was much, much younger I used to put my elbow on the floor and use one hand to wrestle kittens. This resulted in my having scratches from wrist to elbow from the kitten's back paws. I'm not sure I'd recommend this to anybody. I seemed to be immune from infection. However, those cats seemed to adore me when they grew up. That's all I have.
...The vet told me that I should play with her and tease her get her rowdy and it's ok if she bites and scratches because that is her way of playing and she thinks I'm her mom or litter mate. When she gets intense he told me to tug at the scruff.

I just want your opinions because like I said I want to raise the best cat.
Obviously, this "Vet" is one of those very lucky people who has graduated last in his/her class at Vet College...and, despite that, earns the title of "Doctor".

Lili...what does your own common sense - your own "gut feeling" tell you about this "advice"?

If I heard that from a Vet, I'd be looking for a competent feline Veterinarian!

I'll bet a paycheck that, if you follow that advice, you'll next be posting new threads in the Behavior Forum asking how to stop your kitten from biting and scratching you...that's after you return from a trip to your local hospital emergency department having been treated for cat scratch disease!

My own advice is that you continue to cherish your sweet gentle kitten!

As for scruffing your kitten, here's where that comes from:
‘Scruffing’* is a general term for a variety of holds on the skin of the cat’sneck. Grasping the scruff of the neck varies from a gentle squeeze of skin,
to grasping a larger fold of skin with varying amounts of pressure.
Consideration of natural feline behavior can help put this technique into
perspective. Cats grasp the scruff of the neck of other cats in only limited
circumstances. During the first few weeks of life the mother cat may lift
kittens by the scruff of the neck using her mouth. This is a method of transport and immobilization, and not a form of discipline. http://catvets.com/uploads/PDF/2011FelineFriendlyHandlingGuidelines.pdf
(That document comes from the American Association of Feline Practitioners' website as an educational piece for veterinary clinics that may wish to implement a cat-friendly environment - there are some valuable tips in there, especially around "reading" the non-verbal behaviour of your cat....as well as being a great tool for evaluating your own Vet clinic!)

Personally, I would only scruff my cats if, in a real emergency, I would need to control the cat's behaviour for safety sake.
See less See more
Hello!
I have a calico kitten. I live downtown Montreal and want her to be an indoor cat. That being said. I have been putting her on a harness and leash and let her roam on the balcony and take her to parks now and then but only on a leash. Is this a bad idea?
Will she want to be an outdoor cat if I keep doing this?
I live on the second floor. I'm always eith her at all times when she's roaming on her leash. I just want to be the best momma to her and raise her right.

Also...
The vet told me that I should play with her and tease her get her rowdy and it's ok if she bites and scratches because that is her way of playing and she thinks I'm her mom or litter mate. When she gets intense he told me to tug at the scruff.
I just want your opinions because like I said I want to raise the best cat.

Thank you for your time all :)
Lili
I agree with the other posters. Your vet is wrong...and mean!

He's telling youy to get the kitten all excited, then punish it when he does something you don't like BEACUSE you got him all riled up. No fair!

I'd suggest getting a big stuffed animal if you want to wrestle with him. Hold the stuffy by the material at the back, and waggle it at the kitten. Let him kick and bite and scratch the toy as much as he likes. If he gets you by accident simple drop the toy and walk away. Toys are a lot less fun when they don't move, and this way he has a target that won't bleed when he 'gets it'.

I'd also use toys like a laser pointer, or a wand toy. These both keep the fun far away from your body so the kitten won't get confused about what is, or isn't, a toy. This is the best idea if your kitten is particularly feisty, it will encourage him to get all his energy and fighting out, without him thinking that you're just a great big toy from him to hunt and pounce.
Here are a few links from REPUTABLE sites which could help you understand what a kitten needs to do...and how you can provide for those needs and teach appropriate behaviours:
How to Play with a Kitten (no need to register on that very annoying popup window - click "close window")
ASPCA - Virtual Pet Behaviorist - Cats Who Play Rough
http://behavior.vetmed.ucdavis.edu/local-assets/pdfs/Kitten_Play_Rough_Isnt_Right.pdf
A great book is Think Like a Cat by Pam Johnson Bennett. I think you’d enjoy and learn a lot from. They sell it used and new on amazon. I try to give them out to people who adopt from me. A good resource.

[ame="http://www.amazon.com/Think-Like-Cat-Pam-Johnson-Bennett/dp/1579544258/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1338321823&sr=1-3"]http://www.amazon.com/Think-Like-Cat-Pam-Johnson-Bennett/dp/1579544258/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1338321823&sr=1-3[/ame]

Its not recommended to use your hands to play with a kitten or cat because they get use to biting and scratching their people as something that’s ok. I would recommend a wand toy which they can chase or jump in the air after. Or a laser pen with the red dot they can chase. I throw bottle caps and tin foil balls for my fosters” to chase.

I harnessed trained my first cat. I found the best type harness is the ones that kind of look like a shirt. You can find it in the dog section. The strap kind cats can get out of. My cat when frightened would thrash around and jump and get out of the strap harness. He wasn’t able to with the shirt kind.

We love people who want to learn how to enrich their cats lives and be the best cat parents possible. I hope the suggestions help

FYI most vets are dog oriented. It’s hard but not impossible to find a knowledgeable cat vet who understands cat behavior. Ask around at no kill shelters or rescues and find out who they think are the great cat vets in your area.
See less See more
There are remote cat play toys for a reason. That reason is because kittens do not have an off switch! One of the best toys of course is a tackle pillow; about four or six inches long, two to four inches in diameter and stuffed pretty firmly with fluff. My kittens love tackling it after I throw it and then they can bite it and scratch it as hard as they want to and not hurt ME. Cat Dancers, fishing toys, even just a string or yarn on the floor are great remote toys. If a kitten gets assertive and scratches or bites, you tell them OW! or NO! and stop playing; that is what their littermates or mom would do. If they hurt one another the play stops and the kittens learn to not bite or scratch. There is no need for scruffing. If I have an aggressive cat, all I have to do is hiss or spit and my cats back off. A mom yowl breaks up cat fights with one sound. Very effective.
Please also be careful about your cat being tethered on the balcony and make sure she cannot accidently hang herself if she falls over the edge. Walking a cat on a leash is lots of fun sometimes. I used to have five that were leash trained. The only problem I came across was with Spice Cat. She used to climb trees while on the leash and refuse to come down. So I would be standing or sitting at the base of the tree with the leash disappearing up the trunk into the lower leaves waiting for Spice to dain to come down. One time Spice took enough time that the property owners thought I was a crook casing their house for a later burglary and called the police. The cop who came to talk to me had a good laugh once I showed him Spice lying on the branch above my head. The people living in the house actually became good friends once they realized I was not a crook. Waking a cat on a leash is much different than a dog.
Walking a cat on a leash is more like a cat walking YOU on a leash I find (at least with my guys). They meander and wander around and sure as heck aren't going where I want to go. I can't walk Book where I am, he's petrified of cars and there is no area around my apartment that doesn't have cars whizzing by (I have the scars to prove how terrified he gets). MowMow isn't afraid as long as I'm close(he flipped out when SO tried taking him out. He clawed his way across the sidewalk back to my door, howling the whole way), but his idea of being out on the leash is to lay under a bush and watch the world go by..... not so much fun for me standing there like a dope at the other end of the leash.

I agree with not playing directly with them. Inevitably your going to get hurt and scratched and it won't be kittens fault if he was taught to play that way. My guys both play with limbs but know the world "gentle" and if they get rough I just need to remind them with that word and they let go and ease up. I was VERY fortunate that both came knowing that. Book must have had an amazing foster parent as young kitten because he has always been a gentle player and MowMow just seems horrified when he's drawn blood by accident.
See less See more
Well I've got to admit I never tugged at the scruff. When I'd had enough I'd pick the kitten up and stroke it's nose. Never any problems. And they grew out of it. However, I have to add that these were male kittens. (grin)
I have already stopped the rough play. No more scuffing. When she bites I say NO. I've been using the word GENTLE. And yes I did have doubts about what the vet said. It is the very reason I asked my questions on the forum.
Thank you so much for the extremely helpful links and ideas. Does anyone know of a good cat vet in Montreal ?? I had researched the other vet on rate my vet and he had almost perfect scores
Do you think it's to late to teach her the proper play methods at 10 weeks?
It is never too late to teach a cat more socially acceptable play methods. Just keep going with refusing to play when she is too aggressive and rewarding right behavior. It will help.
Do you think it's to late to teach her the proper play methods at 10 weeks?
No, she is still in her kittenhood. She'll learn. You just need to be consistent in your teaching. When she gets rough and hurts you (even a minor twinge) punish her by stop playing with her.

It's always funny to see how my littermates would punish each other. They'd wrestle with arms and feet kicking. Then when one got a little too rough and made claw/teeth to skin contact, I'd hear a squeal. The offended would get up, walk away about 10 feet then stop, drop to their bottom with their back turned to the offender and groom themselves. It was like they were saying "I'm much more civilized than YOU!" Always they'd do their shunning within visual distance of the offender. There was no hiding. The offended wanted to be seen and make a show of it. Then the offender would sit or lay there and look at their play partner with the most bemused expression. It was like they were saying "What did I do?" After a minute or so, they'd start grooming themselves as well, as if to say "See I can be civilized too."
See less See more
1 - 16 of 16 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top