Cat Forum banner

1 - 9 of 9 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,441 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
My friend is an 8th grade english teacher and this is her 3rd year of teaching. They just had the ELA test which is a standardized test. Well she gave the test to 15 students and misread the directions on one part of the test. The students were supposed to only have 45min to complete the section but she unknowingly gave them 60min. So the students will still get to keep their scores but the tests won't count towards statewide statistics. Her supervisor was a little upset but very understanding. a few of the other teachers are very upset at her and called her saying "how stupid she was" "how could you do this" "someone needs to reap the consequences" etc. they want to get her fired but luckily she has tenure. My friend is pretty upset as to how hard the other teachers are being on her. She is surely sorry for her mistake and feels bad about it. I think these teachers are taking this way tooo far. I don't feel standardized testing is very effective anyways. My SAT scores basically said I was a dummy who would never make it through college. Well I graduated cum laude and was a member of 4 honor societies. What do you all think about this?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,480 Posts
As a teacher in training, I have pretty strong opinions on current standardized testing practices. :x

Kris, as your friend is experiencing, one of the nastier consequences of testing is the competition it creates between teachers. There are high stakes involved due to NCLB (No Child Left Behind). A school can have its reputation damaged and jeopardize its funding when test scores don't meet the goals set forth by the federal gov't.

When students don't do well, schools and teachers start looking for someone to blame. The third grade teachers blame the second grade teachers for not preparing the students adequately, there are too many special ed kids and non-English speakers, etc.

While I'm not against testing completely, the current system is responsible for alot of bad blood in schools. I'm sorry to hear that your friend got caught up in it. :(
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
263 Posts
I think that standardized testing is a necessity. The reason that teachers get up in arms over bad scores and statistical errors is because the scores of the school reflect on them as teachers. There is really no other way to make sure that the state funded schools are up to par.

On the other hand, your friend should not have to deal with angry teachers because she made a mistake. There is no reason for them to take it out on her.

I always performed well on standardized testing, and my high ACT scores gave me numerous advantages in college from a research position as an undergraduate freshman to my tuition covered by scholarships. In that regard I will have to respectively disagree that standardized tests aren't important. With that said, I understand that some people just don't do well on them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,441 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
Just reading my post and realizing that I don't sound like someone who graduated with honors. Unfortunately speedy internet chat has led to sloppy grammar mistakes on my behalf. I need to slow down and work on that. But that is a whole other discussion.

Anyways. Sorry for that side tangent.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
6,480 Posts
Parker said:
The reason that teachers get up in arms over bad scores and statistical errors is because the scores of the school reflect on them as teachers.
Actually, teachers don't like them for the exact opposite reason. They don't necessarily reflect a teacher's ability.

There are so many factors which affect student scores, and whether a student tests well is only one of them. A child's socioeconomic level, home environment, parental involvement, preschool experience, and first language (L1) skills are among the many factors which affect student achievement. Some children are simply behind from the beginning, and even with great teaching it is very difficult for them to catch up.

Standardized testing isn't the problem -- it's test scores being considered the only measure of success. :(
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
1,549 Posts
manitu22 said:
I don't feel standardized testing is very effective anyways. My SAT scores basically said I was a dummy who would never make it through college.
I agree on that -- my SAT and ACT scores were horrible, and I'm not stupid, I'm a very good student and always got As and Bs. I just suck at those tests.

I personally think it's crazy that they're going nuts on her...but I'm not a teacher, so that may mean more to them than it does to me. Good luck to your friend, though.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,370 Posts
I am a writer by trade, and I suck at standardized tests. Give me an essay test, and I'll write you a book on the subject. I don't think my mind works in the multiple choice format.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
2,449 Posts
Hippyhart said:
I am a writer by trade, and I suck at standardized tests. Give me an essay test, and I'll write you a book on the subject. I don't think my mind works in the multiple choice format.
Me, too!!!

Although I did so much better on my set of GRE tests than my set of SAT tests. By the time I went to grad school I just didn't care anymore.

Anytime I don't care about something, I do much better.


There was one time my Engineering Calculus professor used a multiple-choice exam. I got a 40 on the exam. Midway through the semester he got replaced by another professor who used a regular exam, and I got a 97 on the next exam. I ended up getting a C in the class :twisted: :twisted: :twisted:
 
1 - 9 of 9 Posts
Top